negative on that one... the only thing i can maybe think could be wrong would be the cable running from the controller to the dongle just because it makes static noise when its twisted around in the controller, but i'm almost thinking that my problem could be that the turtle beach puck could have messed my jack up just from being left in it all the time
even though i'm really easy on both the controller and the headset, the cable end doesn't seem to have the click into place feeling like my old controllers do, and i'm guessing thats just from that big style puck moving around and possibly maybe reaming the connectors out just enough to mess something up... because if i have the connection in the controller and the dongle and pull the cable out of the dongle and plug it back in the speaker comes up on the screen for the voice, but it only stays up for like a second, but if i pull it from the controller and leave it in the dongle, when i plug the connector back into the controller it doesn't show the speaker for chat on the screen at all....
i ordered another puck from turtle beach for my x1's but they sent me one for the x31 and 41's, which from what i read up on sounds like it differs from the x1 connector enough to not work for chat with the x1's, so i'm waiting on another new puck to see what happens